Appearance
Structural AdmissibilityThe question before correctness.
A framework for evaluating theories of everything by what their structure actually supports, not what their authors claim.
A framework for evaluating theories of everything by what their structure actually supports, not what their authors claim.
Before asking whether a theory of everything is correct, ask what kind of work it actually is. Many disputes about contested frameworks (String Theory, Geometric Unity, Loop Quantum Gravity, Wave Relativity, MOND, ΛCDM) collapse into clear structural readings once we settle which bucket the work sits in, and this audit checks a theory's institutional bucket-claim against what its structure actually supports. It walks three legs to catch a theory claiming a bucket it has not earned: are the primitives at the right level, does the work operate at the level it claims, and is the work positioned correctly relative to established physics?
Admissibility does not gatekeep on credentials, journal venue, or institutional affiliation. The crank-or-not test is sociological, and this audit cuts orthogonally to it, so a theory with full institutional infrastructure can fail Leg B2 while an obscure independent-scholar derivation can pass Leg A.